
An Roinn Oideachais agus Eolaíochta
Department of Education and Science
Subject Inspection of Guidance
REPORT
Saint Fachtna’s De La Salle College
Skibbereen,
Roll number: 62480Q
Date of inspection: 16 September 2009
Subject provision and whole school support
Summary of main findings and recommendations
Report on the Quality of Provision in Guidance
This report has been written following a subject inspection in St Fachtna’s De La Salle College. It presents the findings of an evaluation of the quality of provision in Guidance and makes recommendations for the further development of Guidance in the school. The evaluation was conducted over one day during which the inspector visited classrooms, viewed guidance facilities, interacted with students, held discussions with teachers and reviewed school planning documentation. During the evaluation visit, the inspector provided oral feedback on the outcomes of the evaluation to the principal and guidance counsellor. The board of management of the school was given an opportunity to comment on the findings and recommendations of the report; the board chose to accept the report without response.
St Fachtna’s College is a
boys’ second-level school serving Skibbereen and its
rural hinterland, which includes nearly twenty primary schools. Two hundred and
sixty boys are currently enrolled. The school has founded in 1937 by the Institute of the Brothers of the
The ex-quota allocation by the Department for Guidance is eleven hours per week, all of which are used by the guidance department. The current timetable for Guidance is heavily biased towards timetabled class contact with senior cycle classes. The potential breadth of the programme of the guidance department alone is very large, encompassing personal, educational and vocational guidance, and the provision of a service to individual students and to class groups in both the junior cycle and senior cycle. In addition, ongoing collaborative work with staff, middle and senior management, parents and students to form and to maintain the curricular and programme components of whole-school guidance and care of students requires careful planning and is time consuming. The current timetable and consequently, the provision for Guidance is relatively heavily biased in favour of senior-cycle classes. It is recommended that this timetable be reconsidered so that a more flexible and balanced programme might be devised.
Links have already been established between the Guidance and other departments such as special educational needs, Social, Personal and Health Education (SPHE), Religious Education (RE) and Leaving Certificate Vocational Programme (LCVP). This is good practice and prepares the way for collaboration in the delivery of the curricular elements of the whole-school guidance programme, as envisaged in A curricular framework for Guidance in post-primary education, published as a consultative document by the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) in 2007.
The facilities for Guidance are good. An office has been equipped for guidance purposes with the requisite office furniture, storage and information and communication technology (ICT), including broadband internet accessibility. Although the office currently lacks an up-to-date computer, arrangements are in place for the early installation of a machine suited to guidance use. In the interim, use is made of the school’s well-equipped computer room. Guidance lessons are generally timetabled for the computer room, enabling student access to current information. This is commended.
A weekly meeting has been established between the principal and guidance counsellor in addition to a short weekly meeting of all staff. This is good practice. It is noted that the review of current practice is of particular interest during these meetings. Such review is a major component of the planning process and is commended. The size of the school and staff embeddedness in the local community enables the provision of much informal support for students. The staff is commended for this. The formation of a small student-support group is recommended as extension and formalisation of this work. The group should comprise those with core student-support functions, such as the guidance counsellor and special educational needs co-ordinator, and should have clear lines of communication with senior management, staff and parents. Referrals to external agencies are already managed collaboratively by the guidance department, the special educational needs department and senior management. This exemplifies existing good practice, which, in the course of time, will extend to structured collaboration in the assessment of students, the management of reasonable accommodations in the State examinations and in the identification of, and responses to, the needs of students.
A student council was formed in 2008. Representatives were elected democratically. A current priority of the council is the shaping of its constitution. That the council is being formed with reference to the guidelines of the Department of Education and Science and the Office of the Minister for Children is commended.
Whole-school guidance planning is not at an advanced level. In order that progress in such planning is made, it is recommended that a task group be formed according to the recommendations of the School Development Planning Initiative (SDPI) for subject-department planning. The opportunities for development are probably best summarised for St Fachtna’s College in the publication by the Inspectorate of Looking at Guidance in 2009 and recommended for use in the course of planning. This summarises good practice in Guidance in second-level schools and outlines some of the pitfalls best avoided. For example, the structure added to processes by their documentation is considered to be a practice that facilitates efficient planning and continuity of service. In the development of the whole-school guidance plan from a low base, Looking at Guidance will be found to be useful in planning the formation of student-support systems in line with good practice. It is available on the Department of Education and Science website.
It should be noted, of course, that the whole-school guidance plan encompasses a broad range of the business of the school in supporting students, and that the guidance department’s own plan is an additional, but central, component of the whole plan. Issues for consideration include the implications of the school’s policies for guidance department planning and the relationship between the guidance service, briefly described as counselling, and the guidance programme which may include provision by departments such as SPHE, RE, Home Economics and Physical Education (PE). Further information regarding whole-school guidance planning is available on the Department’s website under the Education Personnel tab and in the National Centre for Guidance in Education 2004 publication, Planning the school guidance programme. Guidance department planning is well developed and, as a core element, should be a useful starting point from which to begin the development of the whole-school guidance plan.
In view of current collaborative practice in the school, it is anticipated that the recommended whole-school guidance planning task group will have the relatively simple task of clarifying and noting the links between those providing formal and informal supports. These include the links between the guidance department and special educational needs department, between the recommended student-support group and external agencies, and the links between the core student-support departments and staff, parents and students. Parents and students should be involved in the planning process from the outset and provision should be made for this.
Communication in the school is facilitated by the regular short meetings of all staff and by weekly meetings between the guidance department and senior management. An exemplary scheme of communication between students and older members of the local community has been established in Transition Year (TY).
The optional subjects offered to students are determined by students’ own preferences, both in the junior cycle and in the senior cycle. All students study the available range of subjects in first year. This facilitates informed choice, and is commended. The exposure of students, during the compulsory TY programme, to subjects not already studied for the Junior Certificate examination enables a commendable broadening of the range of subjects available for the Leaving Certificate programme and the LCVP.
The needs of the guidance department should also be considered in the course of planning. Continuing professional development (CPD) is an essential element of the work of the guidance counsellor. CPD is provided mainly by the Institute of Guidance Counsellors (IGC) through its programme of branch meetings and in the management of a system of professional counselling supervision, facilitated by an allocation from the Department of Education and Science. Planning should reflect these considerations.
The lesson observed in the course of the inspection was delivered to a sixth-year class. The use of the computer room for this purpose is commended. The lesson, on the theme of conducting career research was enhanced by the information accessible by students on the internet. A range of relevant websites was suggested as providers of up-to-date information about careers, entry qualifications and educational pathways. A clear introduction to the topic was given and the lesson was clearly identified as one of a series to aid students in the prioritisation of their career preferences, and in the identification of courses and training relevant to their choices. A simple worksheet was used effectively to structure students’ progress through the lesson and to focus attention on the discovery of relevant information.
Effective use was made of questions and other prompts throughout the lesson, encouraging students to reflect on their personal choices and to be responsible for making decisions. Students responded well to those prompts and it was clear that they were familiar with the basics of career choice and of the usefulness of sites such as Qualifax, Careers World and that of the Central Applications Office (CAO) in gathering information. To this end, students were requested to continue with their search for information during the following week using the worksheet that had been distributed. There is a commendable link between this and the subsequent lesson and it serves to emphasise the importance of personal work in vocational choice.
Students remained engaged throughout the lesson, aided by the variety of methods introduced such as the use of the worksheet, computers and questioning. Similarly, an additional information sheet about the arrangement of college open days was distributed and explained at a point in the lesson that provided a commendable break between work being done and that which was to follow.
The school is currently considering the use of standardised psychometric instruments to establish the general ability of students who are newly enrolled in the school. This is commended. Such tests provide useful information that may be used profitably to monitor students’ progress and in the identification of students for whom the additional intervention of the special educational needs department might be warranted. It is noted that collaboration with the special educational needs department has been established and is commended.
Guidance department documentation seen in the course of the inspection is of a high standard. The documents include templates and programme outlines that may be used in discussions with senior management and with other departments in relation to the provision of a comprehensive, whole-school guidance programme.
The following are the main strengths identified in the evaluation:
As a means of building on these strengths, the following key recommendations are made:
The draft findings and recommendations of the evaluation were presented and discussed with the principal and guidance counsellor in the course of the evaluation.
Published, February 2010