
An Roinn Oideachais agus Eolaíochta
Department of Education and Science
Curriculum Implementation Evaluation:
Science and Mathematics 2007
REPORT
Rathcoffey NS,
Donadea, Naas,County Kildare
Uimhir rolla: 16845U
Date of inspection: 25 October 2007
Date of issue of report: 17 April 2008
1. School background and context
2. Provision and use of resources
3. Quality of whole -school planning in Science and in Mathematics
4. Quality of learning and teaching in Science and Mathematics
5. Future development of Science and Mathematics
An evaluation of the quality of teaching and learning of Science and Mathematics in Rathcoffey NS was undertaken in October 2007. The evaluation focused on the provision for Science and Mathematics and on the quality of pupils’ achievement in these curricular areas. This report presents the findings of the evaluation and makes recommendations for improvement.
Two inspectors were involved in the evaluation in Rathcoffey NS. The evaluation involved observation of teaching and learning in all class settings, a review of planning and policy documents and an evaluation of the progress of pupils, including those receiving learning support in Mathematics. A school questionnaire was administered and structured interviews with the principal and class teachers were conducted. The board of management of the school was given an opportunity to comment on the findings and recommendations of the report; the board chose to accept the report without response.
Rathcoffey NS is a Catholic primary school under the patronage of the Bishop of Kildare and Leighlin. It caters for children from Rathcoffey and the surrounding rural area in north Kildare. There are 151 pupils enrolled. The staff comprises 7 teachers - six mainstream teachers including a teaching principal, one learning support teacher and one part-time resource teacher. The original school was established on this site in 1930 and the building was extended in 1950 and again in 1997.
The Principal has been in the post for just over one year. In that time he has evaluated the needs of the school carefully and is continuing the process of putting in place plans and actions that will improve the quality of provision. There is a very good balance of experience among the teaching staff. They work well as a team and are committed to creating a learning environment that nurtures pupils’ well-being, overall development and quality learning. Post-holders carry out their duties competently and diligently and regularly report to their colleagues in relation to aspects of their duties.
The school is well resourced and the principal and staff are consistently adding to the stock of teaching materials and equipment. Substantial investment has been made in equipment for both Science and Mathematics. Appropriately, much of the equipment and materials is stored in a central location and is easily accessible to all teachers. Materials are maintained and replenished by the post-holders who keep a regular audit of the school’s resources. Both post-holders exhibit an admirable enthusiasm for their duties and are keen to promote and support their subject areas throughout the school.
The school has sufficient resources to support hands-on learning activities in all strand units of the Science curriculum. A large selection of science reference books and posters from various commercially available schemes, as well as some computer software and science videos, are available in the staff room. The school grounds and the immediate environs provide a valuable resource for study of the Living Things and Environmental Awareness and Care strands of the curriculum. The school has plans to develop a school garden. Trees and shrubs have been planted and there are plans to install bird boxes and to organise nature trails.
As the school’s most valuable resource, it is appropriate that the teachers be accorded every opportunity to take advantage of in-career training initiatives that present from time to time. The school has been pro-active in inviting experts to the school to contribute to the children’s and the teachers’ knowledge of various aspects of science. Visitors from the Heritage in Schools scheme have worked with pupils in the school grounds. A local historian conducts regular fieldtrips with the senior children expanding their knowledge of local field monuments and of the history of the local environment. Experts from Kildare County Council have focussed attention on bird-watching. Workshops on energy with Sustainable Energy Ireland (SEI) and on composting with the Peatland Conservation Council have contributed to the school’s Green Flag campaign. Visits to the laboratories in Tallaght Institute of Technology are planned for this school year.
The principal and staff are fully aware of the potential of the school’s environment to support implementation of the Social, Environmental and Scientific Education (SESE) curriculum and are eager to increase their own skills and knowledge so that they can provide a developing programme of work and continue to instil in their pupils a sense of pride and ownership of the local environment. This is, indeed, a commendable practice and the staff is encouraged to continue its work in this area.
The school has continuously invested in resources for the teaching of Mathematics and a broad range of structured resources is outlined in an inventory in the school plan. This plan emphasises the importance of practical experiences using hands-on, exploratory approaches and the range of manipulatives and materials acquired facilitates activity-based strategies and a variety of participative teaching. The utilisation of concrete materials and mathematical equipment is sustained in all the mainstream and special needs classes to assist the pupils in their understanding of number operations and concepts across all strands and strand units. While some of the resources are commercially produced many are teacher-generated and are usefully employed to support pupils’ learning through the utilisation of guided-discovery approaches and to facilitate the principle of differentiation. All classrooms have stimulating mathematical displays and illustrations and a maths-rich environment is created with ICT being used effectively to enhance the quality of display.
The whole-school plan for Science aims to provide a clear and coherent approach to teaching Science across the school. Consultation leading to the current draft was completed in December 2005 and, since then, teachers have been refining their perspectives on Science, leading to a review of the current plan in September 2007. The plan includes an account of the school’s vision for Science and an endorsement of the aims of the science curriculum. The main teaching approaches and methodologies are analysed and the staff has explored how the environment can be used to support implementation of the curriculum. The development of the skills of working scientifically and designing and making has been discussed. The plan also includes a comprehensive section on safety. Parental involvement is encouraged and opportunities are provided for parents to view the children’s work. The school plan also includes an extensive inventory of science resources. When the next review takes place, it is recommended that the strand units of the curriculum be divided into two-year cycles and that this plan is enshrined in the whole-school plan. This will be particularly helpful to the school over the next few years as the increasing enrolments will result in split classes and guidance from the school plan will help to ensure continuity and progression. Developing and expanding the role of the curriculum co-ordinators to include the monitoring of the implementation of the school plan should also be considered. The children’s experience of Science could be further enhanced by participation in initiatives such as the Discover Primary Science, Steps to Engineering and the Lego Mindstorms programmes.
A whole-school plan for the teaching of Mathematics, which is underpinned by the principles of the curriculum, was compiled in 2004 and reviewed in 2006. Working collaboratively, the teachers have outlined the school’s rationale for the teaching of Mathematics. The plan sets out a structured programme of work which indicates the manner in which the aims of the curriculum are constructively fulfilled. It ensures that due emphasis is placed on progression and development in the pupils’ knowledge and skills from class to class. An appropriate range of topics, strategies and activities which are designed towards the formation, understanding and linkage of mathematical concepts is provided. The plan specifies clearly the range of approaches and methodologies to be adopted in the teaching and learning of Mathematics and highlights the importance of problem-solving in practical situations. Attention is paid to the enrichment of mathematical language. An appropriate emphasis is placed on oral mathematics. Active learning is encouraged through the purposeful use of the school’s wide range of mathematical resources, manipulatives and equipment. The quality of the school plan facilitates its implementation in the classroom and relates closely to individual teacher planning in providing useful guidance and clarity in the identification of objectives which are outlined in their long-term and short-term preparation.
Confirmation was provided that, in compliance with Department of Education and Science Primary Circular 0061/2006, the board of management has formally adopted the Child Protection Guidelines for Primary Schools (Department of Education and Science, September 2001). Confirmation was also provided that these child protection procedures have been brought to the attention of management, school staff and parents; that a copy of the procedures has been provided to all staff (including all new staff); and that management has ensured that all staff are familiar with the procedures to be followed. A designated liaison person (DLP) and a deputy DLP have been appointed in line with the requirements of the guidelines.
The quality of classroom planning in Science is very good at all class levels and teachers are to be commended for their diligence in preparing short-term and long-term schemes of work that embrace all areas of the curriculum. The long-term planning in Science is firmly grounded in the Primary School Curriculum (1999), and every teacher’s short-term plan includes specific curriculum objectives. An impressive feature of many teachers’ planning is the consistent attempt to integrate the work with other subjects, particularly History, English and Mathematics.
Monthly records are maintained so that appropriate levels of continuity and progression can be achieved. In general these documents are helpful in identifying the range and balance of activities undertaken. However, their value would be further enhanced if they were amended to include comment on the children’s skill development in the areas of working scientifically and designing and making. It is recommended that this issue might form part of the action plan for future provision in this subject area.
All teachers prepare long-term schemes of work for Mathematics that reflect the balanced coverage of the curriculum outlined in the school plan. A very useful template has been devised that indicates the aims and skills to be developed across all the strands and strand units of the curriculum on a monthly basis and reference is made to methodologies, resources, assessment and differentiation. Equally good detail is provided in the short-term templates where the objectives and skills of the fortnightly curriculum to be mastered are highlighted and clarified. Practical tasks, written assignments and ICT activities are prepared, with some attention to differentiation to address the needs of children experiencing difficulty and to ensure that high achievers are suitably challenged. Suitable resources are selected and sourced to support lessons. Much of the work and samples of activities are drawn from the pupils’ environment. The textbook series, Action Maths, which is augmented by samples drawn from other series, is constructively used in all classrooms. Content covered each month is documented in the cuntas míosúil. The inclusion of references to the skills that have been mastered by the pupils will further enhance the effectiveness of these progress records.
The quality of Science teaching in all classes is very good. Scientific language and terminology is used in most classes to help the children to clarify and interpret and to enable them to explore their own ideas and understandings. This focus on language development should become an integral part of all science lessons. Teachers are fully aware of the safety implications of activities undertaken and children are encouraged and enabled to observe safety procedures during all tasks.
Opportunities are provided in all classes for the children to be actively engaged in a wide variety of learning experiences. The pace of lessons is good and the teachers use a range of strategies to both interest and motivate the class. Tasks are suitably challenging and the contexts reflect the pupils’ interests, environment and previous experiences. In most classes, challenging questions are used effectively to consolidate, extend and verify what pupils know and understand. Pupils enjoy science lessons. They work collaboratively in a variety of circumstances involving groups of differing composition and size. Allowing the children greater autonomy in planning and conducting investigations and in deciding how to record results and findings will enhance the provision.
Very good use is made of the school’s wide range of resources to provide high-quality support for learning and teaching. Classrooms are stimulating, well-organised and attractively decorated. Effective use is made of space. All classrooms have nature tables or science tables with a good range of colourful displays. The photographic records of the children’s work displayed in several rooms provide an excellent means of recording.
Assessment of the children’s learning in Science is developing well throughout the school. Children’s progress is assessed, documented and reported at all class levels. The teachers are to be commended on the work being done in this area. This work can be further developed using concept-mapping and portfolios based on the copies and scrapbooks the children are already using.
A high level of awareness is evident in relation to energy conservation and recycling. The school has formed a Green Schools committee. An environmental review has taken place and an action plan to reduce waste has been prepared. The committee also has plans to plant window boxes each October and April, to increase the variety of trees and shrubs in the school grounds, to develop nature trails and develop a school garden. The school has been awarded its environmental Green Flag from An Taisce and the committee is working on the pursuit of the green flag for energy. Thermometers have been placed in all classrooms and an audit of energy consumed for heating and lighting is being carried out in an attempt to reduce energy consumption. The whole committee is to be congratulated on their pro-active approach and on their commitment and dedication to this worthwhile project.
As part of this evaluation, two sets of tasks were administered to the pupils in a number of classrooms. The first set of tasks was used to assess the pupils’ conceptual knowledge. In the strand Living Things, most of the pupils assessed displayed mastery of the concept tested in Human Life and the majority demonstrated mastery of the concept tested in Plant and Animal Life. In Energy and Forces, almost all of the pupils demonstrated mastery of the concepts tested in Electricity and Magnetism. Most demonstrated mastery of the concept tested in Heat. A small number demonstrated mastery of the concepts tested in Forces and in Sound. Fewer than half demonstrated mastery of the concept tested in Light. In the Materials strand, all pupils demonstrated mastery of the concept tested in Properties and Characteristics of Materials while the majority demonstrated mastery of the concept tested in Materials and Change. All pupils demonstrated mastery of the concepts tested in Environmental Awareness and Care. The second set of tasks was used to assess the pupils’ procedural knowledge. Most of the senior pupils displayed mastery of the knowledge and skills required by the task. In the middle and junior classes about half of the pupils mastered the tasks.
Standards of pupils’ behaviour and discipline are high throughout the school. They concentrate well in class, contributing confidently and listening attentively to their teachers and to each other in the oral part of the lessons; they work conscientiously and co-operatively on their tasks. They collaborate well with each other and have a good relationship with their teachers. They show great enthusiasm for school and are observed to be keen learners.
Observation of classroom practice reveals that the overall quality of learning and teaching of Mathematics across the school is very good. The Mathematics curriculum is being implemented effectively and is enhanced by the proficient use of a suitable supply of resources and concrete manipulatives. Experiential learning with reference to pupils’ own experience is a central feature of the provision and topics are introduced, presented and integrated in a manner that fosters pupils’ ability to relate concepts easily to their immediate environment and to practical experiences. Creative, teacher-directed use of concrete resources stimulates discovery learning and accommodates understanding and application of new concepts. Emphasis is placed on the teaching and use of appropriate mathematical language. Talk and discussion are central to the teaching and learning process and, in general, pupils show a very good capacity to apply relevant mathematical terminology accurately and confidently while exploring tasks and explaining processes and outcomes.
While whole-class teaching is the predominant methodology, group teaching is also used effectively in many instances. Opportunities for collaborative learning are accommodated through well-planned and proficiently-organised group activities. This approach fosters co-operative learning skills and facilitates teachers in supporting individual pupils as needed. At most class levels, learning activities are differentiated and matched to pupils’ abilities. A consistently high level of enthusiastic pupil participation in tasks set was a notable feature of all lessons observed. All have a very positive attitude to Mathematics and derive a sense of challenge from their learning.
Planning for early mathematical activities is particularly thorough and pupils at infant and junior levels are generally capable of using and applying relevant mathematical language in completing activities. Maths-rich environments are created and there is further evidence of effective practice in relation to exploring the development of language in the understanding of concepts in number, algebra, measures, shape and space. A commendable variety of games and activities is employed to consolidate new content learned and pupils competently and enthusiastically engage in group work. They are well-trained in mental calculations and can carry out appropriate number operations.
As pupils progress through the school to the middle and senior standards their existing knowledge is purposefully consolidated and built upon and their understanding of concepts and number operations is progressively extended, at a pace to suit their abilities. Clear visual examples are used to explain concepts. Practical and activity methods are a regular feature in clarifying the various concepts and in ensuring that they are explored in a logical and developmental manner. Pupils have access to manipulatives when exploring new concepts. Oral activity, in the form of structured talk and discussion, is employed effectively and the value of mental questions to cultivate speed and accuracy in calculation is clearly understood. The overall standard of mental mathematics is high and pupils display a good understanding of mathematical concepts and an ability to apply them to solving real-life problems. Tables and algorithms are revised regularly. The accurate and confident use of correct vocabulary and terminology by the majority of pupils when discussing mathematical topics and explaining processes is commendable. Pupils’ written work is presented neatly and the work is monitored carefully at every level of the school. Pupils are regularly affirmed and given positive feedback for improvement.
Teacher-designed tests are a standard feature of assessment in most classrooms and assessment tests from the Action Maths scheme are administered. Results of weekly and termly tests are documented and are analysed to inform planning and teaching. The standardised Sigma-T test in Mathematics is administered annually. Results are analysed by each class teacher in collaboration with the principal, learning-support and resource teacher. Results of standardised tests are used when meeting parents and when drawing up individual pupil learning programmes where necessary.
The school has one learning-support teacher who combines the role of learning-support and resource teacher. Together with providing literacy support for twenty-one pupils, she has been providing supplementary teaching in Mathematics for twelve pupils from second to sixth standard. Pupils who are considered in need of extra assistance with numeracy receive tuition on a withdrawal basis, usually in groups of two or three. The learning-support room is bright, spacious and equipped with stimulating material. This includes a number-rich environment and regular access to resources within the school as well as to computer software such as Number Shark and Destination Maths. Content and methodologies are tailored to the individual needs of the pupils and praise and positive reinforcement are used very constructively to motivate pupils’ sense of confidence and achievement. Individual Pupil Learning Profiles (IPLPs) are drawn up for pupils in need of supplementary teaching in consultation with the class teacher. Parents are consulted when profiles are being reviewed and are supplied with copies of IPLPs on request.
The following are the main strengths identified in the evaluation:
· There is evidence of very good practice in the teaching of Science and Mathematics.
· There is a high level of enthusiasm and expertise among the staff in relation to Science and Mathematics.
· Pupils show positive attitudes towards Science and Mathematics.
· Pupils are willing to engage in discussion concerning mathematical and scientific concepts and the majority display a commendable grasp of the material taught.
· Collaborative learning methodologies are used effectively throughout the school.
· Teachers possess very good classroom skills and employ teaching methodologies which reflect a keen understanding of the principles of the curriculum in both subject areas.
· Staff and students and, in particular, the Green Schools committee are to be congratulated for achieving Green Flag status for the school.
· A wide range of equipment and materials is available and is used effectively in the teaching of Science and Mathematics. These resources are well catalogued and are easily accessible.
· The principal and staff are to be commended on the use of the school’s rich environment and on basing the children’s learning firmly within their environment.
As a means of building on these strengths and to address areas for development, the following key recommendations are made:
· Developing and expanding the role of the curriculum co-ordinators to include monitoring the implementation of the school plan should now be considered.
· Reference to the development and progression of the pupils’ skills in both Mathematics and Science should be included in the cuntas míosúil.
· Maths trails to complement the nature and science trails should be developed.
· The school should consider further development of its science provision by participating in initiatives such as the Discover Primary Science, Steps to Engineering and the Lego Mindstorms programmes.
The Inspectorate of the Department of Education and Science wishes to acknowledge the contributions made by the principal and teachers during the course of the evaluation. It is hoped that this report will be directly useful to the school as a basis for review and development of practice at school level. It is anticipated that the composite report on the quality of teaching and learning of Science will serve as a valuable reference at system level and will inform the further development of policy and provision for the teaching of Science.